Skip to content
This website is operated by the following Herbalife Nutrition Independent Member: Andrew Hill, 20 Shakespeare Close, Leicester, LE3 2SX.

How to Meal Prep a Week of Healthy Breakfasts: Shakes vs Overnight Oats vs Eggs

How to Meal Prep a Week of Healthy Breakfasts: Shakes vs Overnight Oats vs Eggs

Breakfast is the meal most likely to be skipped, rushed or replaced by a pastry on the way to work. A little prep fixes that. Here’s an honest comparison of three of the easiest make-ahead breakfasts, and a 20-minute routine to set up your week. This guide is part of our complete UK guide to meal prep for weight loss.

The short answer: overnight oats are the cheapest and highest in fibre, eggs are great for protein if you have a few minutes in the morning, and a meal replacement shake is the fastest and most portion-controlled. All three can work. Choose the one you’ll actually stick to, and make sure it includes protein.

Does breakfast help with weight loss?

Honestly, not by itself. A 2019 review of randomised trials found that eating breakfast didn’t lead to weight loss, and adding breakfast could slightly increase total daily calories[1]. Breakfast isn’t magic, and if you’re genuinely not hungry in the morning, you don’t have to eat.

So why prep it? Because for many people, a skipped breakfast becomes a mid-morning pastry or a bigger lunch. A planned, protein-rich breakfast helps you avoid those unplanned choices[2][3]. The point is control, not the meal itself.

The three options compared

Overnight oats Eggs on toast Meal replacement shake
Rough cost per portion Lowest, often under £1 Low, around £1 About £1.80 with semi-skimmed milk (Formula 1)
Protein Moderate; higher with Greek-style yoghurt or protein powder Good: two eggs give roughly 12 to 14g, plus some from the toast Designed to meet meal replacement standards; check the label
Fibre High (oats) Depends on the bread; choose wholemeal Add fruit or fibre powder for more
Morning time None, ready in the fridge About 5 to 10 minutes, or boil them in advance About 1 minute
Portion control Good if you measure Good Very good, measured by scoop
Best for Budget, fibre, eating at your desk Weekends and slower mornings Busy mornings and structured weight-loss plans

Costs are approximate and vary by shop. Formula 1 is £33.89 a tub at the time of writing (November 2026); see our live price list.

Option 1: overnight oats (prep four at once)

In each jar: 40g porridge oats, 150g Greek-style or high-protein yoghurt, a splash of milk and a handful of frozen berries. Leave in the fridge overnight. Oats are a great source of fibre, and most UK adults need more of it to reach the 30g a day recommendation[4]. Keep jars in the fridge and eat within a couple of days.

Option 2: eggs (prep ahead or cook fresh)

Hard-boil six eggs on Sunday and keep them in the fridge, or bake an “egg muffin” tray with spinach, peppers and a little cheese. Eggs are a cheap, high-quality protein. Pair them with wholemeal toast and tomatoes.

Option 3: a meal replacement shake

Made as directed, Herbalife Formula 1 is designed as a meal replacement for weight control: a measured portion with protein, vitamins and minerals, ready in a minute. In the UK, the approved wording is that substituting one daily meal of an energy-restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss, and substituting two contributes to weight loss[5]. See how many meals a day to replace with a shake, and how to prep shakes the night before.

The 20-minute Sunday breakfast routine

  1. Make two jars of overnight oats for Monday and Tuesday.
  2. Boil six eggs for Wednesday, Thursday and a snack.
  3. Bag up frozen fruit portions for shakes on your busiest days.
  4. Put your shake tub, scoop and shaker together in one cupboard.

Mixing the options keeps breakfast interesting, and it means there’s always something ready.

Andrew’s tip

Pick your breakfast by your morning, not by what’s “best”. If you leave the house at 6.30am, the best breakfast is the one you can have in a minute. That’s why many of my clients use a shake on workdays and eggs at the weekend.

Frequently asked questions

What is the healthiest breakfast to meal prep?

One that includes protein and fibre and that you’ll actually eat: overnight oats with yoghurt and fruit, eggs with wholemeal toast, or a balanced meal replacement shake.

Is it OK to skip breakfast to lose weight?

Research suggests eating or skipping breakfast doesn’t make a big difference to weight by itself[1]. What matters is your total intake across the day.

What is a Herbalife breakfast?

See our guide: what is Herbalife breakfast?

Next, read meal prep on £40 a week or how to stay full on a calorie deficit.

Shop this plan

The Herbalife Ideal Breakfast Kit sets you up with a complete breakfast routine, or start smaller with the Starter Breakfast Kit. Add Oat Apple Fibre for extra fibre in your shake. See all prices on our price list.

Free coaching with every order: message Andrew on WhatsApp.

This guide is general information, not medical advice. If you have a medical condition, are pregnant or breastfeeding, take regular medication or are under 18, speak to your GP before changing your diet. DietPal is run by Andrew Hill, an Independent Herbalife Member who earns money when you buy Herbalife products from DietPal. How I earn money.

References

  1. Sievert K, et al. (2019). Effect of breakfast on weight and energy intake: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ. doi:10.1136/bmj.l42
  2. Betts JA, et al. (2016). Is breakfast the most important meal of the day? Proceedings of the Nutrition Society. doi:10.1017/S0029665116000318
  3. Leidy HJ, et al. (2015). The role of protein in weight loss and maintenance. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. doi:10.3945/ajcn.114.084038
  4. Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (2015). Carbohydrates and Health. gov.uk
  5. Department of Health and Social Care. Great Britain nutrition and health claims (NHC) register. gov.uk

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Where to buy genuine Herbalife in the UK, what to check when your order arrives, and why the cheapest listing isn’t always a bargain.
Which Herbalife products have approved weight-loss claims, which are optional extras, and how to build a simple plan without buying everything.
What’s in each Herbalife breakfast kit, who each one suits, and how to choose between Starter, Ideal and Advanced.
Every Formula 1 flavour available at DietPal, which works best for which recipes, limited editions, and tips to stop flavour fatigue.

Discover more from DietPal

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading